Rational choice theory, grounded theory, and their. Pdf the economics of terrorism and counterterrorism. Rational choice and terrorist target selection request pdf. Yoshimichi sato, 20, rational choice theory, sociopedia. Terrorism in general, and suicidal terrorism in particular, is popularly seen as irrational, but many economists and political scientists argue otherwise. Walt argues that formal approaches have not led to creative new theoretical explanations, that they lack empirical support, and that they have contributed little to the analysis of important contemporary security.
The relevance of the rational choice model springerlink. For instance, global media exposure of terrorist violence and. We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. The cambridge companion to religion and terrorism edited by james r. The rational choice model is highly relevant to revolution, but we must slightly relax its assumptions to explain why revolutions exist in the. Rational choice causes of terrorism view terrorism as a logical political choice among alternative actions crenshaw, 1990. It has affected on individual behaviour and individual choice. These notes outline the standard economic model of rational choice in decisionmaking. Yet, as i hope to show, extremist terrorism can be rational and strategic. The causes of terrorism martha crenshaw comparative. As mosca implicitly points out, if standard rational choice models did not roughly apply to the typical devout muslim, suicide attacks would be orders of magnitude more common. Cleared for public release unlimited distribution asking the right questions.
Generally speaking, microeconomics is the study of behavior based on economic units. Lewis july 2017 skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Major elements of rational choice theory are that individuals 1 study the consequences of crime against the benefits of crime before committing a. As a theory of human behavior, rational choice focuses on both individual and groups as actors in two forms, narrow and broad. This model, drawing heavily on the economic understanding of rationality found in rational choice theory, approaches the rationality of terrorism from a substantive point of view in which the use of terrorism is rational in so far as it is appropriate to the achievement of given goals within the limits imposed by given conditions and. Introduction to choice theory jonathan levin and paul milgrom. The decision to employ terrorism and key components such as target selection are in fact predicated on rational calculations as to the perceived or expected ability of terrorism to achieve ends. Particularly useful is the slutsky equation, which rigorously analyzes the quantity response in. Psychological theories of terrorism premium assignment help. Feb 28, 2011 by defining political economy and war in the broadest sense, this unique handbook brings together a wide range of interdisciplinary scholars from economics, political science, sociology, and policy studies to address a multitude of important topics. This volume includes stephen walts article rigor or rigor mortis.
Hoffman, 1998 political science, lewis, 2003 history, and stout, 2002 psychology. This approach relies on rational choice theory and its derivatives, characterizing islamists as rational political actors that engage in costbenefit analysis and strategic calculation. Criminological explanations for terrorism criminology. May 24, 2016 this model, drawing heavily on the economic understanding of rationality found in rational choice theory, approaches the rationality of terrorism from a substantive point of view in which the use of terrorism is rational in so far as it is appropriate to the achievement of given goals within the limits imposed by given conditions and. The relevance of the rational choice model, the political economy of. It expands on traditional applications of rational choice to allow for altruism as a key motivator for terrorism, and explores how terrorist organizations adapt their strategies to take advantage of changing opportunities. An evaluation of the rational choice theory in criminology.
The present article deals with the ontological problem of applying the rational choice frameworks to the study of terrorism. The main argument of the article is that while the old terrorism can be explained by the rational choice theory its new version represents a substantial departure from rationality. What should you look for as we examine the diverse theories of terrorism proposed by scholars from many disciplines. It testing the application of the rational choice to the old before the end of the cold war and the new after the end of the cold war terrorisms. Rational choice explanation an overview sciencedirect. Discussing concepts of terrorist rationality econstor. Although academics from various disciplines have focused their attention on answering this question, researchers have offered no conclusive explanation. When rational choice theory is applied to the study of terrorism, it is important that attention be given to the. Irrational rationality of terrorism by robert nalbandov dr. After that, i return to the issue of rationalchoice explanations. Karldieter opp has been a major figure in rational choice sociology. Rational choice explanation an overview sciencedirect topics.
The rational choice theory of terrorism was established from economics and applied mathematics, specifically from the game theory. Much of the debate concerning rational choice theory rct is fruitless because many people both critics and defenders fail to correctly understand the role it plays in developing explanations. Rational choice explanations help us to understand the circumstances surrounding terrorist decisions to choose violence. Major elements of rational choice theory are that individuals 1 study the consequences of crime against the benefits of. An empirical analysis of terrorism in the middle east and africa 6 the frustrated state of mind is important by the reasoning of frustrationaggression theory. This paper argues on this basis, terrorism is procedurally rational. They not only deal with methodological aspects 1 but also analyse major issues in society 2. Evolution of the rational choice theory of terrorism. Terrorism and game theory over the last two decades, a small group of analysts in economics and political science have applied game theory to study terrorism,1 which involves the premeditated use or threat of use of violence or force on the part of terrorists to achieve a political objective through.
A framework for assessing counterterrorism actions jonathan schroden, william rosenau, emily warner. This paper has been published in 2006 in public choice. September 2004 1 individual decisionmaking individual decisionmaking forms the basis for nearly all of microeconomic analysis. On rational choice theory and the study of terrorism request pdf. An empirical analysis of terrorism in the middle east and. In this paper, we produce evidence on terrorism being a prevalent issue, present a few pros and cons of applying each one of three selected criminological theories feminist criminology, cultural criminology, and rational choice theory to determine reasons to perform a special type of terrorist act, the jihad, and, after weighting up pros and cons, we come up with a decision on what theory. Mar 25, 2016 the rational choice theory, when applied to an intelligence question of whether a group or individual will do something, can yield effective results that shed light into the mindset of the target. Here, the game theory posits that the choices or actions of a person depend on the choices of other people or groups. Most recently, karldieter opp has provided fascinating studies relating to the transition of the german democratic republic to the federal republic of germany. Rational extremism since september 11, we have been particularly concerned with what is often termed extremist terrorism.
One promising avenue of research is the application of rational choice theory to terrorist attacks and planning. The rational choice perspective assumes that, under conditions of uncertainty, the decision to engage in corporate crime is a function of the perceived costs and benefits of crime relative to the perceived costs and benefits associated with noncrime. Is it useful to discuss causeeffect relationships in terms of a rational choice model. Sep 16, 2014 the three theories including the psychopathological theory, the rational choice theory and the frustrationaggression hypothesis are all psychological theories of terrorism and explain the existence and activities of terrorism. Rational choice theory lindauer lance 20 asserts that rational choice theory is one of the important theories to analyze the issue of terrorism in a framework of political communication. Rational choice theory at the outset, rational choice theory has been the theoretical cornerstone of economics for more than a century but it has since been used in numerous academic fields. A theory premised on bargaining, therefore, would seem illsuited to explaining such violence. Rational choice theory, developed by cornish and clark 1986, is linked to deterrence theory in that individuals make rational decisions to avoid punishment and are deterred by criminal sanctions. Deterrence theory an overview sciencedirect topics. This chapter examines the theory and evidence of the rational choice approach of criminology and applies it to our understanding of how terrorists choose their targets and why they choose some. Rational choice and security studies the mit press. According to van um, the narrow version allows only for action that enhances the personal utility so that individuals act purely selfishly, while a broader. When rational choice theory is applied to the study of terrorism, it is important that attention be given to the derived principles of constrained. By defining political economy and war in the broadest sense, this unique handbook brings together a wide range of interdisciplinary scholars from economics, political science, sociology, and policy studies to address a multitude of important topics.
By directing attention to assumptions andor information about compensated. Scholars from a variety of disciplines have delved into why terrorists exist and how they are motivated e. But this begs the question of what we mean by the terms terrorist and extremist traits that are often in the eyes of the beholder. This paper distinguishes three different senses of irrationality. Terrorism and game theory over the last two decades, a small group of analysts in economics and political science have applied game theory to study terrorism,1 which involves the premeditated use or threat of use of violence or force on the part of terrorists to achieve a political objective through intimidation or fear. This makes this analysis technique perfect for the question of whether isis is willing to conduct a major attack on the united states. Therefore, the actions of terrorists are meant to maximize their goals. Jul 06, 2017 this paper presents a contrasting portrayal, finding that the above representation misunderstands terrorisms fundamental principles. How has criminology contributed to the study of terrorism since 911. What is the relationship between terrorism and such potential root causes as poverty, education, religion, and mental health.
Fullydeveloped economic or econometric models of terrorism are quite rare, however, and often involve such things as psychic costs. Rational choice and religious terrorism chapter 7 the. A growing body of literature criticizes the notion that islamism is sui generis and argues that it could be explained by existing conceptions about human behavior. According to this theory, aggression is the dominant response to the frustration of an ongoing response sequence galtung, 1964, p. In its original version, rational choice theory assumed that people always try to behave as rational actors and that human rationality tends to be almost perfect. We ap proach terrorism as a form of political behavior resulting from the deliberate choice of a basically rational actor, the terrorist organization. Poverty and education at the beginning of the decade, there was widespread belief that pov erty and education were root causes of terrorism. Hoffman, 1998 political science, lewis, 2003 history, and. Terrorism is the irregular use of violence by nonstate groups against nonmilitary targets.
Irrational rationality of terrorism air university. Rational choice theory can be useful to the study of other issues of terrorism, including, for example, the formation of preferences. A rational actor only chooses those actions that he considers as the most effective means to attain his objectives or satisfy his preferences. The rational choice theory of terrorism in particular emerged from microeconomics and applied mathematics especially game theory. The rational choice theory, when applied to an intelligence question of whether a group or individual will do something, can yield effective results that shed light into the mindset of the target. The rational choice theory of terrorism emerged from economics and applied mathematics, especially game theory.
Particularly useful is the slutsky equation, which rigorously analyzes the quantity response in one activity to a price change in another. When rational choice theory is applied to the study of terrorism, it is important that attention be given to the derived principles of constrained utility maximization. Rational choice and security studies presents opposing views on the merits of formal rational choice approaches as they have been applied in the subfield of international security studies. On rational choice theory and the study of terrorism. Aug 21, 2006 when rational choice theory is applied to the study of terrorism, it is important that attention be given to the derived principles of constrained utility maximization. Rational choice deterrence theories assume that government retaliation increases the perceived costs of crime, thereby decreasing terrorist strikes. Testing a rational choice model of airline hijackings laura dugan university of maryland gary lafree university of maryland alex r. In a similar vein, this paper contends that the rational choice model is highly relevant to terrorism including suicidal terrorism. For more on economic theories on terrorism such as game theory or rational choice models, and on related examples, see e.
Close this message to accept cookies or find out how to manage your cookie settings. In this article, we argue that states should also consider raising the expected utility of abstaining from terrorism through rewards. The rational choice theory of terrorism dr simon moss. Rational choice and security studies, critical replies from prominent political scientists, and walts rejoinder to his critics. Rational choice theory, developed by cornish and clark 1986, is linked to deterrence theory in that individuals make rational decisions to avoid punishment and criminal sanctions that deter them. The relevance of the rational choice model by bryan caplan. Terrorism from the rational choice point of view springerlink. It also takes first steps toward integrating the knowledge. In a similar vein, this paper contends that the rational choice model is highly relevant to. The rational choice perspective assumes that, under conditions of uncertainty, the decision to engage in corporate crime is a function of the perceived costs and benefits of crime relative to the perceived costs and. Two mechanisms or processes are analysed to explain how the purpose of rational choice theory is realized. Rational choice approaches to reducing terrorist violence would suggest raising the costs of terrorism through punishment, thereby reducing the overall expected utility of terrorism. What matters and is rational choice theory helpful. Rational choice theory states that offenders weigh.
801 1562 447 1205 765 238 70 387 1526 1530 820 53 697 701 1472 645 347 920 224 1077 534 1495 1162 844 612 1173 378 1514 45 980 1329 734 1494 1495 1063 811 1197 1032 348 630 939 462 1456 493 1330 601 503 1121 1023 171